withSimplicity | March 25, 2025

Best Eyeshadow for Your Eye Color: How to Use Color Theory to Make Your Eyes Pop

eyeshadow-blog.jpg__PID:ff6bdf6c-c280-4a44-94b5-4382ffe811b7

When it comes to makeup, one of the most transformative things you can do is choose the right eyeshadow colors. While there’s no one-size-fits-all approach, a little understanding of color theory can help you select shades that truly enhance your natural eye color. Whether your eyes are blue, green, brown, or hazel, specific colors can make your eyes appear brighter, more vibrant, and even more defined.

In this guide, we’ll break down the best eyeshadow colors for each eye color, explain the science behind these choices, and provide expert tips on how to make the most of your eye makeup. Plus, we’ve curated palettes to help you achieve the most stunning looks for your eye color.

Ready to go ahead and build your palette? Check out our Custom Mix-and-Match Eyeshadow Palettes!

How does color theory relate to eyeshadows?

Color theory is the fundamental principle that guides how we combine colors to create harmony and contrast. In makeup, the idea is to enhance your eye color by choosing shades that either contrast with or complement it. The basic rule is that colors opposite each other on the color wheel will create the most dynamic contrast, making the eyes stand out.

Here’s an example:

Warm tones (like oranges and reds) will contrast beautifully with cool-toned eyes, like blue and green.
Cool tones (like blues and purples) provide the best contrast for warm-toned eyes, such as brown or hazel.

By understanding this concept, you can strategically choose your eyeshadow colors based on your eye color to make them pop!

Best Eyeshadow Colors for Blue Eyes

Blue eyes are one of the most striking eye colors, and they look particularly vibrant when paired with warm tones. These warm shades enhance the cool undertones in blue eyes, making them pop.

Here are some colors we think complement blue eyes very well:

Cashmere & Hazelnut: The rich, warm orange undertones in Cashmere and Hazelnut contrast beautifully with the cool tones of blue eyes, making them appear even brighter.
Toffee & Suede: Softer warm tones like Toffee or Suede can accentuate blue eyes without overwhelming them. These shades create a natural, balanced look.
Riviera & Merino: These earthy shades of orange, red, and brown give blue eyes a dramatic, fiery contrast that makes them stand out.

Best Eyeshadow Colors for Green Eyes

Green eyes are unique and mesmerizing, often shifting in color depending on the light and environment. To bring out their full intensity, opt for shades that create a striking contrast.

Here are some of our favorite eyeshadows to make green eyes pop:

Dahlia: This Deep Plum Shimmer shade intensifies green eyes and makes their vibrant color pop.
Mulberry: Purple is the complementary color to green on the color wheel, and using purple shades will create a bold, dramatic contrast that makes green eyes stand out.
Creme Brulee: this coool-toned shimmery brown has ever-so-slight purple undertones that compliment green hues in the eyes.

Best Eyeshadow Colors for Brown Eyes

Brown eyes are versatile and can carry a wide range of shades. From cool tones to warm metallics, brown eyes look amazing with many color combinations.

Here are some of our go-to colors to make brown eyes pop:

Seine (Deep Blue – Matte): This deep blue provides a striking contrast against rich brown tones, adding an element of surprise while making the eyes pop.
Mulberry (Deep Purply-Pink – Matte) & Dahlia (Deep Plum – Shimmer): These shades of purple bring out the warmth in brown eyes, creating a sultry, sophisticated look.
Suede (Light Golden Brass – Shimmer) & Medallion (Golden Olive – Shimmer): These warm metallic shades highlight the golden flecks often found in brown eyes, giving them an illuminated, radiant appearance.

Best Eyeshadow Colors for Hazel Eyes

Hazel eyes are known for their complexity, with a mix of green, brown, and gold tones. These multifaceted eyes can benefit from a variety of eyeshadow shades that bring out their natural beauty.

Here are some other color options we like to use to accentuate hazel eyes:

Medallion: This golden olive tone emphasizes the green in hazel eyes, making them appear more vibrant
Suede & Moscato: These warm gold shades highlight the golden undertones often found in hazel eyes, adding depth and warmth.
Dahlia & Mulberry: These deep plum and burgundy tones provide a bold contrast to hazel eyes, making them appear more striking.

How to Apply Eyeshadow to Enhance Your Eye Color

Once you’ve selected the perfect eyeshadow shades for your eye color, it’s time to apply them. Here are some tips to help you get the best results:

For a Natural Look: Start with a neutral base shade that matches your skin tone. Apply a medium-tone shade in the crease to add depth, and finish with a light shimmer on the lid or inner corner to brighten your eyes.
For a Bold Look: Layer deeper shades along the outer corners of your eyes and in the crease to create dimension. Use a darker eyeliner to define the eyes even further.
For a Brightening Effect: To make your eyes appear more awake and vibrant, try applying a pop of complementary color along the lower lash line.