-
Skincare{ $store.xMobileNav.close() }, 0)" >
-
By Product{ $store.xMobileNav.close() }, 0)" >
-
By Concern{ $store.xMobileNav.close() }, 0)" >
Makeup{ $store.xMobileNav.close() }, 0)" >Bath + Body{ $store.xMobileNav.close() }, 0)" >More{ $store.xMobileNav.close() }, 0)" >Explore{ $store.xMobileNav.close() }, 0)" >-
Blog{ $store.xMobileNav.close() }, 0)" >
Experience{ $store.xMobileNav.close() }, 0)" > -
- Log in
Pressed Eyeshadow - Refills
(32)
$16.00
Unit price / perEarn points every time you order and unlock more as you grow!
- 3%–6% back in rewards for most members
- Up to 15% back for our VIP Tier
- Redeem for discounts or exclusive rotating products
A pressed shadow formulated using only clean, pure ingredients that are easily buildable so you can keep it simple or go bold.
Refills do not come with a compact, but fit perfectly into our Empty Magnetic Eyeshadow Palette.
-
Ingredients
Full Ingredient List
*Oryza Sativa (Rice) Powder, Mica, Silica, Magnesium Stearate, *Vitis Vinifera (Grape) Seed Oil, *Origanum Vulgare (Oregano) Leaf Extract, Thymus Vulgaris (Thyme) Extract, *Olea Europaea (Olive) Leaf Extract, *Rosmarinus Officinalis (Rosemary) Leaf Extract, Lavandula Angustifolia (Lavender) Flower Extract, Hydrastis Canadensis (Goldenseal) Root Extract, *Simmondsia Chinensis (Jojoba) Seed Oil, Tocopherol (Vitamin E), May Contain/Peut Contenir [+/-]: Titanium Dioxide (CI 77891), Iron Oxides (CI 77491, 77492, 77499), Mica *Certified Organic
Espresso Full Ingredient List
*Oryza Sativa (Rice) Powder, Mica, Boron Nitride,*Simmondsia Chinensis (Jojoba) Seed Oil, Zinc Stearate, Hydrastis Canadensis (Goldenseal) Root Extract, *Origanum Vulgare (Oregano) Leaf Extract, Thymus Vulgaris (Thyme) Extract,*Cinnamomum Zeylanicum (Cinnamon) Bark Extract, *Rosmarinus Officinalis (Rosemary) Leaf Extract, Lavandula Angustifolia (Lavender), Panthenol, May Contain/Peut Contenir [+/-]: Titanium Dioxide (CI 77891), Iron Oxides (CI 77491, 77492, 77499) *Certified Organic
-
Product Details
- Size: .08 oz / 2.2 g
- Consistency: Pressed Powder
- Good For: 12 Months After Opening
Due to the use of natural ingredients, there may be color/scent variation between batches.
-
Shade Descriptions
- Cacao: Deep, Cool Brown (Matte)
- Cashmere: Warm-Toned Brown (Matte)
- Chai: Cool-Toned Taupe (Matte)
- Chestnut: Deep Neutral Brown (Shimmer)
- Creme Brulee: Cool-Toned Shimmery Brown (Shimmer)
- Dahlia: Deep Plum (Shimmer)
- Espresso*: Deep, Neutral Brown (Matte)
- Eiffel: Silver (Shimmer)
- Hazelnut: Warm Medium Brown (Shimmer)
- Medallion: Golden Olive (Shimmer)
- Merino: Bone Shade (Matte)
- Moscato: Shimmery Champagne (Shimmer)
- Mulberry: Deep Purply-Pink (Matte)
- Pinch: Mauvy Midtone Pink (Matte)
- Riviera: Bright, Warm Apricot (Shimmer)
- Seine: Deep Blue (Matte)
- Starlight: Shimmery Light Pink (Shimmer)
- Suede: Light Golden Brass (Shimmer)
- Toffee: Light Pinkish-Brown (Matte)
*Formerly our Deep Brown Eyebrow Powder
-
How to Use
Remove eyeshadow from clamshell and pop into slot in palette. To remove or switch a color, simply use the mini magnet pull to gently remove the pan from the palette.
Beauty Built on Trust, Not Trends.
Ingredient Integrity
Plant-first formulas, supported by science, that deliver real results while adhering to our 100% non-toxic values and clean standards.
Eco Responsibility
Committed to sustainable packaging, regenerative-focused sourcing, and recycling initiatives that reduce waste and support a healthier planet.
People First
Dedicated to partnering with organizations that fight human trafficking, address food insecurity, and promote child welfare both locally and globally.
Tutorials
Enhance your Natural Beauty
All Ages. All Skin Colors. All Beautiful.
Our Clean Promise
- 5 stars: 26 (81%)
- 4 stars: 4 (13%)
- 3 stars: 0 (0%)
- 2 stars: 1 (3%)
- 1 star: 1 (3%)
I overtime colors I ordered!! Great product!!
I moved my single eyeshadows into this palette to condense them into one. Much easier to use in the morning when they are all together and easier to travel with, as well.
My favorite eyeshadows! I use moscato and starlight daily for the perfect neutral with a shimmery pop of color. The eyeshadow doesn’t crease and it glides over my lids seamlessly. Good staying power!
Starlight is too warm. It was supposed to be a cool toned pink but looks more of a champagne pink which pulls gold on me. Pretty disappointing. And can’t return it so money wasted.
I bought this to keep multiple shadows in one place. It's great and easy to replace with refills.
I like the eyeshadow pallette and refils are easy to put on and the colors were a good match. The eyeshadow doesn't irritate my eyes or burn my skin. Thank you to WithSimplicity for coming out with eyeshadow that is easy and non-toxic.
I use the Merino, like the way it goes on. Love all the products I have tried With Simplicity. So glad they are all non toxic!
This is exactly what I needed! It is easy to use and I love the fact that I can change out the colors when I want. I don't have a reaction to it like I have with most other makeup companies. Definitely will buy again.
The texture & shimmer of this shade is PERFECT. It leans just a hint yellow, and I do wish it was a little more cream and less yellow, but I'm able to blend it with cooler and warmer eyeshadows without issue. I'm loving it.
Love the Chai (matte finish) eyeshadow color! Has a smooth and silky texture. I would love for you to make a duo compact with color combinations...i.e. matte or shimmery.
I love this eyeshadow. It goes on smooth and silky and lasts all day. I like the colors that have a shimmer the best.
I do like your eye shadow and the color too!Happy it doesn’t leave left over on my cheeks!Also stays on all day!
I wanted to love this eyeshadow, and it was on my list of trial and error due to the sensitive nature of my skin. The pigment and texture is great, however I did have an allergic reaction on my eyelids characterized by burning, weeping skin, itchiness, and once I washed off, small welts appeared. Not sure which ingredient(s) caused this issue, but for me, this eyeshadow caused a painful reaction, which two days later, I am still trying to heal.
Hi Doris,
We wish you would have emailed us before leaving a review! Can you please reach out to our customer service email so we can assist you?
Email: info@withsimplicitybeauty.com
Thanks!
- wS Team
Love the eye shadow. Wish there was a set of shadows in one compact instead of having a bunch of singles 😉
I love this eyeshadow the color is beautiful and a small amount goes a long way!
Classic colours apply beautifully to enhance natural features.
These eyeshadows are great. They stay put and do not get small fragments in my eyes like others. The colors are natural.
It’s clean, last all day, comes off with water and a norwex facial cloth and makes my green eyes pop.
Since I live in MX, I just recently received them, and have not yet had a chance to evaluate, other than the colors are lovely, and true to the site colors. I expect I will be very satisfied since they are toxin free.
I absolutely love this shadow. I love that I’ve found pigmented shadows from a clean makeup company
The color is beautiful and feels like silk!
I love the pressed eyeshadow overall. It goes on smooth and lasts all day without creasing! The only downside that I found is that the colors of the actual eyeshadows are lighter than in the pictures.
The pressed eye shadow goes on vey nicely.
I purchased Moscato for a neutral lid and under brow base. It stays on well. Looking forward to purchasing other colors.
Unfortunately, the color was not what I was wanting the picture on line seemed quite different than the actual color. I was not able able to return it so I’ll give it away.
Very pretty color. Isn't a long wearing eyeshadow.
It is a great neutral color. I don't feel like it is a long wearing eyeshadow. Definitely need to touch up if you were going out into the evening.
Just what I wanted!
I love it!
One of my daily colors. Goes on evenly and stays on.
I always make a mess with loose powders so these pressed eyeshadows are right up my alley. They apply well (no mess) and last all day. The colors are gorgeous!!! You just have to see them in person! Riviera is one of my favorite shades so far.
I love these eyeshadows so much! Moscato is my absolute staple and holy grail! I use it as eyeshadow and as highlighter on my face. I love the variety of colors and textures. I like to mix and match shades and do all sorts of looks. They stay on all day and are easy to apply and blend. 100% recommend!
Keep up w/ withSimplicity
Be the first to know about new collections and exclusive offers.
About withSimplicity
withSimplicity is a clean beauty brand out of Harrisonburg, VA online that only uses the cleanest and purest of ingredients in every product, and is your go-to to buy organic skincare & makeup products
Colors for products are optimized for and best-viewed in Google Chrome.
withSimplicity is a clean beauty brand out of Harrisonburg, VA online that only uses the cleanest and purest of ingredients in every product, and is your go-to to buy organic skincare & makeup products
Colors for products are optimized for and best-viewed in Google Chrome.
© 2026,
withSimplicity.