Free Shipping $99+*
-
Skincare{ $store.xMobileNav.close() }, 0)" >
-
By Product{ $store.xMobileNav.close() }, 0)" >
-
By Concern{ $store.xMobileNav.close() }, 0)" >
Makeup{ $store.xMobileNav.close() }, 0)" >Bath + Body{ $store.xMobileNav.close() }, 0)" >More{ $store.xMobileNav.close() }, 0)" >Explore{ $store.xMobileNav.close() }, 0)" >-
Blog{ $store.xMobileNav.close() }, 0)" >
-
- Log in
Just Dropped.
SPF 15 Lip Balm
Non-Nano Zinc Oxide | Nourishing Oils | Spearmint Essential Oil
New SPF Lip Balm
Retractable Brow Pencil
(17)
$26.00
Unit price / perEarn points every time you order and unlock more as you grow!
- 3%–6% back in rewards for most members
- Up to 15% back for our VIP Tier
- Redeem for discounts or exclusive rotating products
Shape, define, and fill with precision.
Our Retractable Brow Pencil allows for natural-looking definition with a smooth-glide, buildable formula. Featuring an angled tip to mimic natural hairs and a spoolie brush for seamless blending, this dual-ended pencil offers effortless control—no sharpening required.
Formulated with plant-based, vegan ingredients, it not only enhances the look of brows but also supports their overall health. Vitamin E conditions and helps shield brow hairs from environmental stressors, while Castor Seed Oil deeply nourishes and promotes the appearance of fuller, stronger brows. Jojoba Oil mimics the skin’s natural sebum to keep brows soft, hydrated, and flake-free. The result is naturally defined brows with a healthy, polished finish.
-
Ingredients
Ingredient List
Copernicia Cerifera Wax (Carnauba Wax), Euphorbia Cerifera (Candelilla) Cera, Simmondsia Chinensis (Jojoba) Seed Oil, Olea Europaea (Olive) Fruit Oil, Coconut Oil, Caprylic/Capric Triglyceride, Ricinus Communis (Castor) Seed Oil, Melaleuca Alternifolia Leaf Oil May Contain: [+/-] Titanium Dioxide (Ci 77891), Iron Oxides (Ci 77491, 77492, 77499)
-
Product Details
- Size: .0063 oz / .18 g
- Consistency: Pencil / Matte
- Good For: 12 Months After Opening
Due to the use of natural ingredients, there may be color/scent variation between batches.
-
How to Use
First, brush out brows with the spoolie end to help separate any hairs. Use the pencil end to apply color in small, upward strokes to mimic brow hairs in desired shape. Brush through with spoolie again to distribute color and make brows look more natural.
Beauty Built on Trust, Not Trends.
Ingredient Integrity
Plant-first formulas, supported by science, that deliver real results while adhering to our 100% non-toxic values and clean standards.
Eco Responsibility
Committed to sustainable packaging, regenerative-focused sourcing, and recycling initiatives that reduce waste and support a healthier planet.
People First
Dedicated to partnering with organizations that fight human trafficking, address food insecurity, and promote child welfare both locally and globally.
Tutorials
Enhance your Natural Beauty
All Ages. All Skin Colors. All Beautiful.
Our Clean Promise
I have dirty blonde eyebrows and ordered the deep taupe shade which was a great match. I do wish the formula was a little less dry so it would glide a hair easier but overall, it’s not a deal breaker, I’ll order again.
This eyebrow pencil is by far the best method I’ve used to fill in and define my eyebrows. The tip is the perfect shape to give good definition and coverage. The color is the perfect match AND it stays all day!
My hair is a combination of true Black and natural cool White! An unusual combination but I am sure there are other women for whom many brow colors don't work because they have a warmth to them. There are many greying women who need makeup! I was about 20 when I started getting White hair (as did my daughter). Hope to be seeing this soon!
HI Lydia,
I'm sorry you're haviing trouble finding a brow product that works for you. Have you considered our Eyebrow Powder in the shade 'Charcoal'? It's a cool-toned deep grayish color that I think will work perfectly for you!
If you have any questions, please don't hesitate to reach out.
- wS Team
I love this brow pencil. Softer, creamier texture than most stiff brow pencils (which means you don’t have to press hard to use it). Lightly brush brows after applying to give a more natural hair-like look to your brows.
The old formula was amazing but the new one is just not good you need to push hard just to make it work. Such a bummer was my fav
Keep up w/ withSimplicity
Be the first to know about new collections and exclusive offers.
About withSimplicity
withSimplicity is a clean beauty brand out of Harrisonburg, VA online that only uses the cleanest and purest of ingredients in every product, and is your go-to to buy organic skincare & makeup products
Colors for products are optimized for and best-viewed in Google Chrome.
withSimplicity is a clean beauty brand out of Harrisonburg, VA online that only uses the cleanest and purest of ingredients in every product, and is your go-to to buy organic skincare & makeup products
Colors for products are optimized for and best-viewed in Google Chrome.
© 2026,
withSimplicity.